Container shipping lines are drawing sharp criticism from shipper representatives and industry observers over pricing tactics that critics say would attract immediate regulatory action in any other commercial sector. The Global Shippers Forum (GSF) has led the charge, with director James Hookham telling Seatrade Maritime News that competition regulators “would be all over this if it happened in any other commercial sector,” adding pointedly: “Welcome to container shipping!”
The controversy centers on the simultaneous implementation of peak season surcharges (PSS) and capacity reductions. According to Drewry Shipping Consultants, carriers have announced PSS of $1,000–1,600 per FEU for cargo to North Europe and the Mediterranean, even as they continue to announce further cuts to offered capacity. Hookham compared the practice to a hotel “charging extra in the school holidays whilst at the same time mothballing half of its rooms,” or a supermarket “charging you extra because its checkouts are busy even though half of them are closed”.
The rate environment on Asia-Europe routes has reflected this dynamic. Drewry reported that rates from Shanghai to Genoa increased 6% to $4,436 per FEU after three consecutive weeks of stability, while Shanghai to Rotterdam rates held steady at $3,496 per FEU. Four blank sailings were announced by vessel operators for the coming week, down from five the previous week. Hookham described the combination of higher rates and capacity management with evident irony: “This is what ‘capacity management’ looks like”.
The criticism extends beyond surcharges to the broader use of blank sailings as a routine commercial tool. Industry analysts have noted that cancellation rates now exceed pandemic-era levels, suggesting that capacity restriction has become a profit strategy rather than an emergency response to disruption. Critics argue that when forwarders adjust services they face market punishment, while carriers engaging in the same behavior have it described as “market discipline”—a double standard that reflects the power imbalance between fragmented shippers and a consolidated carrier oligopoly.
The competitive dynamics vary significantly across trade lanes. On the Pacific, spot rates have declined for the seventh consecutive week, with two November general rate increases (GRI) failing and expectations that a December 1 GRI will also fail amid increased capacity and softening demand. Zim has announced a third express service on the Pacific, with the ZX3 service potentially adding six ships of 4,250 TEU each for a weekly rotation from Xiamen and Shanghai to Los Angeles. Blanked sailings on the Pacific are expected to increase to 10 voyages in the coming week, up from four in the prior seven-day period.
Meanwhile, Linerlytica reported that the Gemini Cooperation will be the first alliance to return all of its services to the Red Sea route, with its AE1/NE2, AE2/NE1 and AE3/NE3 loops reverting to the shorter route effective from December and January. The rapid influx of new capacity to both Arabian Sea and Red Sea ports continues to overwhelm regional ports, with total capacity waiting at anchorages across the Middle East and Indian subcontinent rising to a record high of over 500,000 TEU. Elevated spot rates on Far East to India and Middle East trades are attracting larger vessels, driven mainly by MSC’s deployment of 24,000 and 16,000 TEU ships despite berthing delays at Khor Fakkan and Jeddah.
The regulatory landscape remains fragmented. While South African competition authorities have pursued price-fixing cases against major carriers for historical general rate increase coordination, and India’s Shipping Ministry has sought exemptions for vessel-sharing agreements from competition law, the kind of coordinated capacity and surcharge behavior currently under scrutiny on Asia-Europe routes has not triggered formal action from European or UK regulators. The GSF’s public criticism appears designed to pressure authorities into examining whether the combination of surcharges and blank sailings crosses the line from legitimate capacity management into anti-competitive conduct.
For shippers, the practical consequences are tangible. The proliferation of surcharges reduces pricing predictability and complicates budget planning, while blank sailings create supply chain uncertainty. Hookham’s characterization of the industry’s pricing opacity as a “tax on importers” echoes broader frustration among cargo owners who lack visibility into how rates are set and why capacity is being withdrawn when demand ostensibly justifies additional sailings. Whether regulators will respond to these concerns remains an open question, but the GSF’s escalating rhetoric suggests the shipping industry’s pricing practices are entering a period of heightened scrutiny.
← Frontpage